COLA Disappointment: Why 2025 Could Be a Tough Year for Retirees

shutterstock.com

Here we go again—another year, another round of tweaks to Social Security that’ll likely leave retirees and workers scrambling. It’s almost as if the administration enjoys keeping everyone on their toes. With 2025 just around the corner, a handful of key changes are set to shake up the landscape of Social Security. And spoiler alert: they’re not all sunshine and rainbows. From cost-of-living adjustments to earnings caps, here’s what you need to brace for in the coming year.

The official COLA calculation is still waiting on the Labor Department’s Consumer Price Index data, which will be out on October 10. But don’t hold your breath for a windfall. The Senior Citizens League, an advocacy group that tracks these things, is predicting a paltry 2.6% increase. If that estimate holds, it will be the smallest raise retirees have seen since 2021—just when inflation is taking an even bigger bite out of everyone’s wallet.

But here’s the kicker: even with this measly increase, retirees in some states might still see a little more in their pockets—thanks to their already higher Social Security benefits. It’s not that the government suddenly got generous; it’s just math. Those who were already receiving larger checks will get a bigger boost in terms of dollars, even if the percentage is the same for everyone.

Let’s take a closer look at the details.

  1. A Measly Cost-of-Living Adjustment (COLA)

Social Security benefits are supposed to help retirees keep up with rising costs, thanks to automatic cost-of-living adjustments (COLAs). But don’t get your hopes up too high. This year saw a 3.2% bump in benefits, but 2025’s projection is a paltry 2.63%—and that’s if inflation doesn’t rock the boat even more. Translation? Seniors should buckle up for a tighter budget. If you thought pinching pennies was fun, just wait. Maybe it’s time to pick up that side gig you’ve been avoiding or find creative ways to cut expenses, because the buying power you once enjoyed is dwindling fast.

  1. Higher Earnings-Test Limits—But Don’t Get Too Excited

For those retirees who aren’t quite ready to hang up their working hats, there’s a little good news: the earnings-test limit is expected to increase in 2025. In 2024, the limit was set at $22,320 for those under full retirement age, and $59,520 for those hitting that milestone within the year. In 2025, this cap is likely to rise, allowing you to earn a bit more without your Social Security benefits taking a hit. Sounds great, right? But don’t pop the champagne just yet—unless your goal is to offset that puny COLA increase. Consider holding off on ramping up those work hours until the new year, when you might actually keep more of what you earn.

  1. Watch Out, High Earners: The Wage Cap is Rising

Social Security’s funding relies heavily on payroll taxes, but here’s the kicker—not all your income is subject to these taxes. Enter the wage cap, which currently stands at $168,600. If you’re one of the lucky few raking in the big bucks, brace yourself for an increase in 2025. Higher earners might see more of their paychecks funneled into Social Security taxes, which means it’s time to strategize. Chat with a tax professional or rework your budget because Uncle Sam is ready to take a bigger bite out of your hard-earned money.

  1. Higher Earnings Thresholds for Work Credits

To cash in on Social Security benefits, you need to earn enough work credits over your career—typically 40 credits. Right now, each credit is worth $1,730, but come 2025, that number is set to rise. Part-timers or those hustling to rack up credits, take note: you might need to up your game. If the threshold goes up, so must your income if you want to keep pace. Keeping an eye on these changes is key, because missing out on credits now could haunt you in retirement.

Not Just Retirees: Workers, You’re in This, Too

These changes aren’t just a headache for retirees—they could throw a wrench in the plans of current workers as well. Keeping up with Social Security’s ever-changing rules is essential if you want to safeguard your financial future. With inflation still playing havoc, even a modest COLA might not be enough to maintain your standard of living. The media, as always, has been quick to trumpet the supposed benefits of these adjustments, but the reality is far less rosy.

Retired Workers by State: Who’s Getting the Biggest COLA Boosts?

While the Social Security Administration will finalize the 2025 COLA after the Labor Department releases the Consumer Price Index data, estimates suggest a 2.6% increase. Retirees in certain states will see larger dollar raises, thanks to their already hefty benefits. States like New Jersey, Connecticut, and Delaware top the list, with monthly increases ranging from $50.60 to $54.60 if the COLA sticks at 2.6%. Of course, this doesn’t mean everyone in these states is sitting pretty. Higher median incomes drive higher benefits, but for many, it’s just a drop in the bucket compared to the cost of living.

Top 10 States with the Largest COLA Bumps in 2025

The Social Security Administration’s 2024 statistical supplement lays it all out. Here’s a look at the 10 states where retirees are expected to see the largest COLAs in 2025, based on the highest median monthly benefits for retired workers as of December 2023:

  1. New Jersey: $2,100
  2. Connecticut: $2,084
  3. Delaware: $2,064
  4. New Hampshire: $2,039
  5. Maryland: $2,008
  6. Michigan: $2,005
  7. Washington: $1,992
  8. Minnesota: $1,982
  9. Indiana: $1,952
  10. Massachusetts: $1,946

Retirees in these states are starting from a higher baseline, so they’ll see a larger dollar increase, even if the percentage stays the same. For example, if the 2025 COLA is indeed 2.6%, the average retiree in New Jersey could see an extra $54.60 a month, while the average retiree in Massachusetts could get about $50.60 more. Sure, it’s not going to let anyone retire to a beach house, but hey, every dollar counts when you’re trying to keep up with skyrocketing grocery bills and utilities.

The Bottom Line: More Changes, More Uncertainty

Whether you’re already drawing benefits or planning your retirement, the Social Security landscape is shifting yet again. Higher earners, part-timers, and gig workers all need to stay alert. Sure, the media will have its spin, but the reality is clear: these changes aren’t exactly life-changing unless you’re already at the top of the income ladder. Keep an eye on your finances, adjust where you can, and be prepared—because Social Security’s twists and turns are far from over.